ish’s blog
A blog. By ish.Archive for Media
The new ad…
Channel 7 has refused to air our new ad, which we had planned on launching during the closing ceremony.
Basically, they suck. Enough said – here’s the ad.
The ad will be shown simultaneously on all of the pro-free speech TV stations in this great land of ours (well at least those stations with ads – i.e. Nine, Ten and SBS).
Thankfully the only good shows that 7 have (and that’s not a lot) are also available via download elsewhere… I’ve survived without watching any Channel 7 since the 8th of the 8th, and now that I know they are basically a puppet of the Chinese propaganda bureau I’ll be steering clear for good.
If you too want to ditch 7 but are worried about missing out on Lost or whatever other crap you are addicted to, check out the Australian iTunes Store that now offers TV shows and movies.
Channel 7 second chance via GetUp! ‘repechage’
GetUp! are going to give Channel 7 a second chance in the media freedom olympics when they attempt to air another pro-human rights advertisement for the closing ceremony.
In one sense it is quite ironic that they pulled our original ad. It must be about the only ad they haven’t shown during the coverage (which from all accounts had been riddled with a seemingly endless barrage of commercials).
If you missed the ad, here it is again for your viewing pleasure…
The Seven ad fiasco highlighted on Media Watch
After the Channel 7 decision to censor the ATC TV ad, I had contemplated notifying ABC’s broadcasting watchdog – Media Watch. Of course, they were already on the ball and tonight ran a comprehensive story on the issue.
I love Media Watch. Nice work Mr Holmes.
By the way, you can view the ad via the ATC website here.
At least Australia has media freedom, right?
Despite (or in line with) the public dispute between GetUp and Channel 7 this week, the network failed to air our ad. The paid advertisement urging PM Rudd to speak up for Tibet whilst in China for the Olympics was produced by GetUp and the Australia Tibet Council (of which I am a director), had free-to-air approval and was appropriately booked. Yet, unbelievably, Channel 7 refused to run the ad, citing a bunch of crap excuses.
Regardless of whether Seven took this decision under its own direction or were pressured into this by someone else (such as the IOC, as has been postulated elsewhere), this raises huge questions about media freedom – not just in China, but right here in Australia.
Amnesty International and Reporters Without Borders (amongst many other organisations including ATC) have been trying to highlight the lack of media freedom within China during the lead-up to the Olympics. Of course, incidents like this one with Channel 7 in Australia are even more disturbing as they highlight the reach of China’s media censorship beyond its own national borders.
I spoke at a public rally last weekend relating to the actions by European Satellite TV company, Eutelsat, in pulling the broadcast into China by the New York based, independent Chinese-language news network NTDTV. Reporters Without Borders have further details on their site regarding Eutelsat’s disgraceful actions, including a lenghty transcript of a discussion between a Eutelsat employee and someone posing as a Chinese Propoganda Department representative. Of course, this would be bad enough if it was a Chinese-based company, but Eutelsat is headquarted in France.
This is a worrying trend, but not a new one. You can find out more by running the incredibly ironic Google search – ‘Google, China and internet censorship’.
Just not in China.
And maybe not for too much longer here either.
Australian diplomat to visit Tibet on Chinese chaperoned tour
Following yesterday’s staged ‘media tour’ of Lhasa, China has approved a chaperoned tour of foreign diplomats.
Let’s hope they get to see what’s really happening, not just what their tour guides allow. We need to continue to call on the Chinese to allow full and open access to independent observers and unfettered access to the international media to ensure the safety of Tibetans within Tibet.
Yesterday’s tactics by the Chinese show a flagrant disregard for media freedom and transparency. We can only wonder what access the foreign media will have during the Olympics.
Monks interupt journalists ‘tour’ and talk to foreign media
A ’stage-managed’ media tour by foreign journalists to Tibet has been interupted by Tibetan monks who have used the opportunity to get their story out to the international media. After about 15 minutes of talking to the foreign press, the monks were whisked away by Chinese police. We hold grave concerns for their safety and will be calling on our Prime Minister and Foreign Minister to ensure that the monks are unharmed and are released immediately.
The following is the full text of the media release from the International Tibet Support Network (ITSN). Footage of the interaction between the monks and the media can be seen at CNN and SkyNews.
Dozens of Tibetan monks disrupt Chinese government organized media tour of Tibet
Monks shout: ‘Tibet is not free,’ risking their lives to send message of freedom to the world
A group of Tibetan monks disrupted a tightly controlled Chinese government media tour in Lhasa today — the only foreign media that has been allowed into Tibet since widespread protests of Chinese rule gripped the nation. As over 20 journalists and their government handlers toured the Jokhang temple in Lhasa, several dozen monks — at great risk to their personal safety — began shouting: “Tibet is not free!” and asserting that the Dalai Lama was not to blame for the recent protests. The monks were immediately taken away by police officers.“In Tibet, where the free expression of political views is met with incarceration and torture, these monks risked everything to show the world that Tibet is not free,” said Lhadon Tethong, Executive Director of Students for a Free Tibet, “While the Chinese government tries to paint a picture of criminal Tibetan riots and many in the press focus on ethnic tensions, the fundamental issue is freedom. The Tibetan people are not and never will be content under Chinese rule. “
The Chinese government has a long history of organizing state guided tours of Tibet in order to present their biased view of life under occupation. Though this humiliating tactic is well known to Tibetans, this is the first time they have disrupted such a tour on this scale.
“The actions of monks, nuns, and ordinary Tibetans in almost every region of Tibet point to a nationwide uprising,” said Tethong, “Tibetans have suffered under Chinese rule for half a century and in this year of the Olympics – with all eyes on China – Tibetans are risking everything to achieve a free Tibet. This is the uprising of a people against their oppressor and the only possible outcome is freedom.”
This action comes on the heels of Beijing’s announcement that over 660 Tibetans have ’surrendered’ in the wake of last week’s protests. Tibetans and supporters maintain that Tibetans – knowing the consequences of detainment in one the world’s most notorious prison systems – would never give themselves up to Chinese authorities and the arrests are the result of harassment, door-to -door searches, intimidation, and coercion.
We the media…
As the media lock-down continues in Lhasa and other regions across the Tibetan plateau, I’ve noticed a lot of global media agencies with forms like these below their stories (this one from the BBC).

The last point is of course the trick – don’t “endanger yourself or others, take any unnecessary risks or infringe any laws” to get the true story out of Tibet. Unfortunately there is no other way. A big thank you to all of the brave tourists and other independents who have managed to get reports, images and footage past the Chinese military and out to the world. Without their courage (and skill!) we would be completely powerless to help defend human rights.